The J.Crew Factory Walker Vest (5 Reasons Why I Love It)7 min read

The J.Crew Factory Walker Vest has long been a favorite here at Gentleman Within and for good reason.

The best seller, J.Crew Factory Walker Vest is one of the most worn articles of clothing in my wardrobe. I wear it almost year-round with exception to those scorching hot summer months.

Safe to say that it’s one helluva stylish, versatile and affordable garment. In fact, good friend, Brock McGoff over at The Modest Man shares similar thoughts about the trusty fall layering piece.

J.Crew Factory Walker Vest Review

^{Subscribe to the Gentleman Within YouTube channel.}

In this review, I’ll highlight 5 reasons why I love the J.Crew Factory Walker vest, give you JCF Walker vest styling inspiration, where I see room for improvement and wrap things up by providing a few viable alternatives.

Before we get started, (on a related note) you can check out this article on how to wear a puffer vest without looking like the Michelin Man.

A Little Background

J.Crew Factory’s Walker vest is a casual, lightweight quilted vest (gilet for those across the pond).

I like the JCF Walker Vest so much that I’ve acquired 4 (soon to be 5) vests in 4 versatile colorways — black, navy, burgundy and olive. They’re definitely a part of my fall essentials.

The black, navy and burgundy vests are older and so they have the original J.Crew Factory branding, while the olive vest is J.Crew Mercantile branded.

FYI, earlier in 2019, J.Crew Factory officially changed its name from J.Crew Factory to J.Crew Mercantile which was really confusing. They’ve since changed back to JCF.

5 Reasons Why I Love The J.Crew Factory Walker Vest

Now let’s get into the 5 main reasons why I love the J.Crew Factory Walker Vest so much.

1. The Walker Vest Is Stylish

Below are some images of me wearing the ever stylish Walker vest through the years.

A big reason why the jacket is stylish is because of the casual quilted pattern and trim fit. Overall it’s just a well-fitting garment that is lightweight and wears snug against the body.

I love that I can wear it as a standalone top layer in warmer weather and as a mid-layer as the mercury begins to drop. 

You can wear it over a sweatshirt or long sleeve henley and over a flannel button up. Or you can wear it under a denim jacket, and even under a blazer. Granted it’s not the warmest layer, but it gets the job done.

Ultimately, there’s no denying the styling potential of the JCF Walker vest. If you have one, how do you wear it?

2. The Walker Vest Is Versatile

Not only is the JCF Walker vest stylish, but it’s immensely versatile.

I created some content last year around styling a puffer vest (opens in YouTube) which included several outfits anchored by the Walker vest.

As mentioned before, it’s so versatile that you can wear it as a standalone piece and you can wear it under pretty much any jacket style you desire.

For example, it’s perfectly paired with a waxed canvas chore jacket, car coat or even a field jacket. You can even wear it over top of a denim jacket to channel some Marty McFly Back To The Future fashion.

3. The Walker Vest Is Functional

To me, functionality is just as important as style. If I’m wearing something and it’s the most stylish article of clothing, but doesn’t have functionality, then it’s not really worth wearing.

The JCF Walker vest functions as a perfect top layer in warmer weather or a mid-layer in slightly cooler weather. It has just enough insulation to keep me feeling comfortable, while not sacrificing style points.

The design is simple, it has two front pockets to hold keys, mints or any other small EDC items. There’s a small interior pocket on the left side to hold anything else that you want close to your body. FYI, the button was removed with the new J.Crew Mercantile design and so my olive vest has no button on the inside pocket.

Additionally, on the side/back of the vest there are side tabs along with 4 buttons so that you can adjust the fit of the vest. If you prefer a roomier fit, leave as is, but if you’re like me and prefer a tighter, slimmer silhouette go ahead and cinch it in.

4. The Walker Vest Is Durable

I’ve had my Walker vests for many years now and they get plenty of wear. Since they’re usually worn over top of a light or mid-weight layer (away from the skin), I haven’t had to wash them much (if at all). The material is durable polyester and the colors have not faded. 

I’ve had my black vest the longest and it’s evident that it’s more worn in than the others. It feels slightly less structured than my other vests. This could also be due to a different design too. Looking at the details, the lining is olive as opposed to the tan, cotton twill lining of the other vests.

Regardless, these Walker vests will give you plenty of mileage over the years.

My Vest Details

• Fill: 100% Polyester
• Lining: 100% Cotton
• Made In China
• Size XS

5. The Walker Vest Is Affordable

And finally, the Walker vests are just plain affordable.

J.Crew Factory is known as the much more affordable alternative to its sister companies, J.Crew and Madewell. Of course the QC and overall quality of materials may not be as good, but JCF has always been a great value.

The J.Crew Factory Walker vest comes in at $79.50 retail, but I’d never buy it at full price, especially considering JCF is always running promotions.

At more than half off, the JCF Walker vest is a steal and some. Counting cost per wear, these vests are one of the best value items in my closet. And with the popularity of these vests, JCF often refreshes with new colorways.

I just checked and they actually have a flannel-lined vest in a grey/teal-esque colorway. Another versatile option that could add a little weight to these vests, making them even more ideal for fall weather.

Check Walker Vest Price

J.Crew Factory Walker Vest Sizing

You can find the JCF Walker vest in sizes XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL. They fit pretty true to size and run a little bit on the shorter side, though vests shouldn’t be worn long anyway.

I’m 5’6″, 135 lbs and the XS fits me spot on.

Room For Improvement

While I love my Walker vests, not everything is perfect. Here’s what I don’t like about them.

This is a minor nitpick, but I feel like the fit of the vests could be improved slightly. While the vest is zipped up, it’s a little bit roomy in the mid-section that can cause an unflattering silhouette while sitting down. Then again, that’s only the case when I’m not layering much underneath the vest. And so the extra room is actually helpful when layering.

Another thing about the vests is that they’re a little too lightweight. I wear it more so for style than for warmth. For colder weather, I’m talking anything 50 and below, I’d opt for a down vest which is much more insulating.

But, as I mentioned above, they do have those new flannel-lined vests recently added to their collection. I think I may have to pick one up to see if it’s warmer than the originals.

Walker Vest Alternatives

Here are a handful of alternatives (at varying price points) to the J.Crew Factory Walker Vest.

• Bluffworks Horizon Quilted Vest – $108
• Bonobos Fleece Lined Golf Vest – $88
• Brooks Brothers Diamond Quilted Vest – $298
• Rhone Midtown Vest – $158
• Peter Manning Flatiron Vest – $148
• Banana Republic Water-Resistant Quilted Vest – $148
• J.Crew Sussex Quilted Vest – $98

A note: J.Crew mainline has a similar piece; the Sussex quilted vest (which I recently picked up) with eco-friendly PrimaLoft, that’s much higher quality and at a higher price point, accordingly. I may put out a video comparing the two in the future.

Conclusion

In the end, the J.Crew Factory Walker Vest is stylish, versatile, functional, durable and affordable. And it’s the combination of these things that makes this casual lightweight, quilted vest one of my favorite pieces in my wardrobe.

Onto you, what are your thoughts about the trusty Walker vest?

Let’s continue the discussion over in the Gentlemen Within Private Facebook Community.

Looking forward to seeing you in there.